Clinton Semi-auto Ban, McCain Gun Show Ban and Kohl Lock Up Your Safety Killed in U.S. Senate 

South Dakota Gun Owners E-mail Alert
PO Box 3845, Rapid City, SD  57709
(605) 737-5583
LibertyTeeth@sdgo.org        http://www.SDGO.org
 

 

(Tuesday, March 2, 2004) – Congratulations!  Thanks to your hard work, and the efforts of other no-compromise groups all over the U.S., the gun control laden S. 1805 was defeated just hours ago, 90-8. 

Before the final vote was taken, the ill fated law suit protection bill included the Lock Up Your Safety amendment, a ten year re-enactment of the Semi-auto Ban, a new list of debilitating requirements designed to put gun shows out of business, and a new law allowing hunting rounds such as the 30-06 to be added to the banned list of “cop killer bullets.” 

Earlier, the NRA told members who called about S. 1805 that they would not oppose the bill, even when it was laden with these anti-gun amendments.  Their plan was apparently to get this gun control abomination into committee, where they hoped to strip it back down to the underlying liability bill.  But this is an incredibly risky game, especially considering that President Bush has stated that he supports a renewal of the Clinton Semi-auto Ban, and the House Leadership has indicated that they may follow the President’s lead. 

But thanks to your stand, the NRA finally decided to oppose the bill. The strong message you sent to your Senators and to the NRA, asking them to oppose S. 1805 if it was loaded down with gun control provisions, defeated one of the worst anti-gun bills to be seen in the last decade.  

The following is a description of the critical provisions that were tacked on to the lawsuit protection bill before it was soundly defeated.  It is written by Gun Owners of America, http://www.gunowners.org 

Lock Up Your Safety Requirement 

Senator Herb Kohl (D-WI) offered this gun control amendment last week.  It would require all handgun purchasers to pay an implicit "gun tax" by requiring them to buy a trigger lock when they purchase their handgun, irrespective of need.  In addition, the amendment would create a broad and implicit cause of action against gun owners who fail to actually use the storage device to lock up their firearms.  Of course, a locked gun then becomes unavailable for self-defense.  The Senate passed the Kohl amendment 70-27. 

Feinstein Semi-auto Ban 

The Senate voted 52-47 in favor of the Feinstein semi-auto amendment.  This amendment would extend the ban that was signed into law by President Clinton in 1994 -- a ban which outlaws certain magazines and more than 180 types of semi-automatic firearms. Unless Congress authorizes such an extension, the ban will sunset in September 2004. 

McCain Gun Show Ban 

Senator John McCain (R-AZ) offered this amendment to outlaw the private sale of firearms at gun shows, unless the buyer agrees to submit to a background registration check.  The language could effectively eliminate gun shows because every member of an organization sponsoring a gun show could be imprisoned if the organization fails to notify each and every "person who attends the special firearms event of the requirements [under the Brady Law]."  Thus, if the person responsible for handing out "Brady pamphlets" took a break to go to the bathroom, everyone responsible for the event could be sent to prison.  The McCain amendment passed 53-47. 

Ammunition Restriction Study 

This amendment, offered by Senators Bill Frist (R-TN) and Larry Craig (R-ID), passed the Senate 85-12.  Among other things, the language of this provision would commission the Attorney General to determine whether the ban on so-called "cop killer" ammunition should include superior performance bullets in popular hunting calibers such as the 30-06. 

GOA also offers this analysis: 

The good news is that the attempt to renew the Feinstein semi-auto ban is dead... for now.  Of course, there are still semi-auto ban bills pending in the House and Senate, and we can expect Feinstein to again offer her gun ban as an amendment to some other "must pass" bill. 

The bad news is that the prospects for getting any kind of legislation to the President's desk this year to protect gun makers is very slim. 

Today's vote makes it very difficult for a pro-gun senator to offer this bill as an amendment to another bill.  After all, anti-gunners can demand that any provision to protect the gun industry now be offered as a "package" with the anti-gun amendments that were attached to the bill over the last couple of days. 

It would have been far better for Majority Leader Bill Frist (R-TN) to have brought this Senate bill to the floor in such a way that NO gun control amendments could have been offered.  Doing so would have involved using parliamentary tactics that are somewhat difficult to detail in an e-mail alert.  But the Senate has often used these tactics in the past.  A vote to pass a "clean bill" could very well have succeeded, as almost 60 Senators had cosponsored the underlying legislation. 

 

SDGO would like to thank all of its members who took action this past week.  Thanks to your calls and e-mails, gun owners have won the first round in the battle against renewing the Clinton Semi-auto Ban.  Keep up the good work! 

Return to News and Updates